Tanzania
Consumer Advocacy Society lawyers Fatma Karume (R) and Beatus Malima
(C) in discussion at the High Court in Dar es Salaam yesterday with
state attorney Alesia Mbuya, who is representing the government in
petition the society has lodged against 1,000/- simcard tax. This was
moments after the case was adjourned. (Photo: Omar Fungo)
The mobile phone companies are MIC Tanzania Limited, Vodacom, Airtel,
Zanzibar Telecom Limited and Tanzania Telecommunications Company (TTCL).
The companies requested to be part of petitioners in the case through an
affidavit avowed by advocate Tumaini Shija which the court said it
would allow on condition that it is submitted by October 15, next week.
Judge Mujuluzi maintained that the state has no good reasons to object
the mobile phone companies’ request to join the petition filed by TCAS
noting that the preliminary objection will now be amended so as to
recognize them as a part of petitioners.
He made it clear that he wants both sides to find an amicable solution
acknowledging on one hand that the government needs revenue but on the
other hand ‘consumers’ rights must be observed.’
“After the mobile phone companies complete and submit their affidavits,
the High Court will meet on October 21, this year to rule whether the
1,000 simcard tax should stay or not,’ Judge Mujuluzi ruled.
In filing the case, TCAS asked the court to nullify the legislation
passed by the parliament requiring every mobile user to be deducted
1000/- monthly as simcard tax, claiming that the majority of simcard
users in the country cannot afford the expense.
According to the petition, the legislation goes against the country’s mother law especially on right to information.
Furthermore, the petitioners requested the court to order the Minister
of Finance and Economic Affairs through the Tanzania Revenue Authorities
(TRA) not to implement the law until the ruling of the petition.
Deputy Attorney General George Masaju and Principal State Attorney Edson
Mweyunge objected to the application which was submitted on Monday by
Advocate Fatuma Karume and Beatus Malima who represent the companies.
According to Advocate Mweyunge, the application is before the court but
the applicant did not ask for leave of court to represent other parties.
“According to the law, an applicant who wishes to represent many parties
is to ask for leave of court first,” established Advocate Mweyunge.
The Deputy Attorney General and Mweyuge are the representatives of the
Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs while the Attorney General is
the respondent in the case.