Friday 13 September 2013

Tanzania wades into Uhuru, Ruto cases at ICC

Kenya’s Deputy President William Ruto reacts as he sits in the courtroom.  
Posted  Thursday, September 12  2013 at  08:19
In Summary
According to Mr Werema’s letter, allowing Ruto to skip some portions of the trial would help enhance co-operation between the court and state parties.


Dar es Salaam. Tanzania has written to the International Criminal Court (ICC), supporting Kenya Deputy President William Ruto’s appeal to be tried in absentia.
Attorney General Frederick Werema filed the letter on Monday in an interesting development confirmed to The Citizen yesterday by Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation minister Bernard Membe.
In the letter, Mr Werema communicates the government’s intention to act as a friend of the court with the purpose of offering briefs regarding ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda’s appeal against the decision to excuse Mr Ruto from attending all sessions of his trial in The Hague. Mr Ruto has been allowed to skip some sessions to allow him to execute his duties as Kenya’s deputy president.
According to Mr Werema’s letter, allowing Ruto to skip some portions of the trial would help enhance co-operation between the court and state parties. The AG is not satisfied that critical issues were considered by the chamber regarding the right of trial in the presence of the accused as provided for in the Rome Statute.
“The brief will observe that, in certain circumstances, the rights of the accused, the rights of the victims and the rights of other interested constituencies such as voters in democratic states can all be accommodated in an effective and meaningful fashion within the court’s framework and without any negative impact on the court’s aims,” the letter reads in part.
Mr Werema says that as a friend of the court, Tanzania can help the ICC adopt a broad and flexible interpretation of Article 63 of the Rome Statutes on the presence of an accused person in court.
“An interpretation which encourages state cooperation in the widest possible set of circumstances and without jeopardising the constitutional responsibilities of leaders,” he says. The AG adds that the Tanzania government’s brief will consider the balance to be struck between those subject to the court’s jurisdiction but who also occupy high office.
A plenary of 14 judges rejected Mr Ruto’s earlier request for trials to be moved to Kenya or Tanzania after it failed to draw the support of at least ten judges after only nine voted in favour.
Mr Membe told The Citizen in a telephone interview yesterday that Tanzania’s decision was in solidarity with Kenya, which recently filed a petition with the ICC, requesting that President Uhuru Kenyatta and Mr Ruto be excused from attending their cases in person to enable them to run the country. “Their constitution says the President and his deputy must not be out of the country at the same time.  If the ICC adopts a contrary position, it could lead to a constitutional crisis,” he said.
Mr Membe also revealed that Kenya had asked all 33 members of  the African Union (AU) who were also signatories to the Rome Statue to write to the ICC in favour of the petition.
The minister said following concerns that the ICC was only targeting African leaders, AU leaders would next January deliberate on whether member countries should withdraw from the ICC en masse.
“Kenya, as we know, has already embarked on the process and other countries will in due course discuss if it is tenable to remain as members of the ICC in future,” Mr Membe said.
Mr Ruto and radio announcer Joshua Sang on Tuesday pleaded not guilty to crimes against humanity following  the 2007/8 post-election violence in Kenya that left over 1,000 people dead and displaced 600,000 others.
President Kenyatta, Mr Ruto’s former rival and now his political ally, will be tried on similar charges in November
SOOURCE: THE CITIZEN