Sunday, 16 June 2013

Economists fault Mgimwa’s budget

By  Ludger Kasumuni, The Citizen Reporter  (email the author)

Posted  Saturday, June 15   2013 at  09:24
In Summary
They said although some exemptions have been done away with, still big companies continue to enjoy tax holidays which have nothing to do with increasing tax base in terms of attracting more investors.

 
Dar es Salaam. Economists have identified major gaps in the 2013/14 budget, including upholding tax exemptions to big investors and the failure to address key matters in relation to transforming the country into a gas economy.
They said although some exemptions have been done away with, still big companies continue to enjoy tax holidays which have nothing to do with increasing tax base in terms of attracting more investors.
Speaking at the event organised by KPMG yesterday, Prof Humphrey Moshi, a senior lecturer of economics at the University of Dar es Salaam ,said fundamentally the revenue sources remain the same.
“The country could have the capacity to collect more revenue in case dealers in the natural resource sector were subjected to pay more taxes and have less exemptions,” said Prof Moshi.
Making comparative analysis for East African countries, Prof Moshi said that Kenya had the biggest tax base and that was why it was the least dependent on foreign aid.
“Kenya’s dependency on foreign aid is only five per cent, while Tanzania’s is over 30 per cent. There is a need to reduce further this dependency so that the country can have resilience against external shocks triggered by the volatile global economy,” said the learned economist.
Explaining on the exclusion of fiscal policies governing the running of oil and gas sector, he wondered why there was a hole in the 2013/14 government budget statement.
“I have not seen sound measures being taken to address preparations towards managing a gas economy,” he said.
He also criticised the projection of attaining single digit inflation based on Consumer Price Index (CPI), which he said it had nothing to do to address inflation at household level budgets.
“It does not reflect the real picture at household level. The good indicator is food inflation, but again food inflation depends on the vagaries of weather. When there is good rain and good harvest inflation comes down and vice versa,” he said.
For his part, KPMG Tax director David Gachewa seconded the arguments saying fundamentally the revenue sources were still the same, proof that the country still maintains a narrow tax base.
“In the past, promises to widen tax base were made, but this is yet to be translated into action. Kenya has a stronger tax base than Tanzania. We have to emulate them,” Mr Gachewa said.

While Tanzania -- second largest economi in East Africa -- projects to collect over Sh18 trillion ($11.3 billion) in 2013/14 financial year, Kenya plans to collect $20 billion, Uganda $5.37 billion and Rwanda $2.02 billion, according to him.